Pierre Steiner apresenta seu artigo ‘Radical views on cognition and the dynamics of scientific change’.
Palestrante
Pierre Steiner (Université de Technologie de Compiègne - Sorbonne Université)
Comentador
Celso Neto (Dallhousie University)
Artigo
Radical views on cognition and the dynamics of scientific change
Resumo
Radical views on cognition are generally defined by a cluster of features including non-representationalism and vehicle-externalism. In this paper, I concentrate on the way radical views on cognition define themselves as revolutionary theories in cognitive science. These theories often use the Kuhnian concepts of “paradigm” and “paradigm shift” for describing their ambitions and the current situation in cognitive science. I examine whether the use of Kuhn’s theory of science is appropriate here. There might be good reasons to think that cognitive science is in a situation of foundational crisis, but that does not entail that the classical paradigm (computationalism) is currently displaced to the benefit of a new paradigm. Larry Laudan’s theory of research traditions is more enlightening than Kuhn’s theory for describing the scope and ambitions of radical views on cognition, and their relations with an anti-intellectualist tradition in philosophy.
DOI
https://doi.org/10.1007/s11229-019-02268-9